The reviews for Darksiders III reveal a polarized reception, with significant criticism directed at combat mechanics and the lack of a map, while visuals and character development received praise. Players appreciate the engaging story and exploration elements, but many feel the game falls short of the expectations set by earlier titles in the series, often comparing it unfavorably to the original games. The incorporation of Souls-like elements has also sparked mixed reactions, highlighting the game's struggle to balance its identity within the franchise.