Old Market Simulator Analysis on Niklas Notes

Old Market Simulator

Game

(released 10 months ago)

Alcedo Games

Gamersky Games

Alcedo Games

TL;DR

It is a multiplayer simulation game where players manage a market on a cozy island town. Players can farm, raise animals, and sell goods while competing with others to be the best merchant. Expect seasonal events and the joy of hiring employees to help with the daily grind.

View on Steam

Genres:

Farming

Life Sim

Resource Management

Tags:

Exploration

Simulation

Management

Agriculture

Life Sim

Immersive Sim

Resource Management

Trading

Farming

Multiplayer

Co-op

Inventory Management

Online Co-Op

Physics

First-Person

Atmospheric

Stylized

Medieval

Economy

Likely Inspirations:

Animal Crossing

Factorio

Harvest Moon

Stardew Valley

Two Point Hospital

Steam Review Analysis – Total (updated Jul 26, 2025, 1:16 PM)

Disclaimer: This analysis is independently conducted and is not affiliated with Valve or Steam.

Review Summary - 3,870

89%

Very Positive

2791

355

81%

Purchased on Steam

655

19%

Purchased Elsewhere

0% Primarily Play on Deck

Playtime Statistics

Playtime Overview

Estimated Playthrough Time

20.90 hrs

Min Playtime

0.08 hrs

15th Percentile

6.17 hrs

Median Playtime

19.28 hrs

85th Percentile

50.08 hrs

Max Playtime

1398.07 hrs

Conclusion

Overall, players appreciate the co-op gameplay, charming graphics, and variety of activities in Old Market Simulator, but many express frustration over slow progression, repetitive tasks, and the controversial use of AI art. The lack of a tutorial and issues with gameplay mechanics also detract from the experience for some players, while the game's relaxing nature and engaging mechanics continue to attract a dedicated player base.

Strongly Positive

Co-Op Gameplay

Players enjoy the cooperative aspect of the game, finding it more engaging and fun when played with friends.

~8%

Positive

Variety of Activities

Players appreciate the diverse range of activities available, such as farming, fishing, and crafting.

~6%

Relaxing Experience

Many players find the game to be a relaxing and enjoyable way to spend time, especially in co-op mode.

~4%

Charming Graphics

The game's low-poly art style and charming details create a cozy and inviting atmosphere.

~3%

Content Depth

Players note the game has a significant amount of content, providing hours of gameplay.

~3%

Fun Mechanics

The game features enjoyable mechanics, such as the fishing mini-game, which players find well-designed.

~2%

Neutral / Mixed Opinions

Negative

Slow Progression

Players express frustration with the slow progression in the game, which can lead to boredom.

~5%

Repetitive Tasks

Players find the repetitive nature of tasks, especially in solo play, to be frustrating and tedious.

~4%

Lack of Tutorial

The absence of a comprehensive tutorial leaves players feeling lost and confused about game mechanics.

~4%

Gameplay Mechanics Issues

Players express concerns about the game's mechanics, particularly regarding inventory management and task automation.

~2%

Strongly Negative

AI Art Controversy

Many players are disappointed with the use of AI-generated art in the game, feeling it undermines the artistic integrity.

~2%

This analysis is powered by OpenAI’s language models and may occasionally contain inaccuracies. For the most precise details, please consult the reviews directly on the official Steam store page.

Share this analysis and support this page: